Diagnostic Accuracy of the HACOR Score and Updated HACOR Score for Predicting Noninvasive Ventilation Failure in Adults with Acute Respiratory Failure: A Systematic Review
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.65759/mc7fmx17Keywords:
HACOR score, noninvasive ventilation, acute respiratory failure, treatment failure, intubationAbstract
Background: Noninvasive ventilation (NIV) failure in acute respiratory failure carries high mortality, and delayed intubation worsens outcomes. The HACOR score (heart rate, acidosis, consciousness, oxygenation, respiratory rate) and its updated version aim to detect failure early. Objective: To synthesise the diagnostic accuracy of both scores for predicting NIV failure in adults with acute respiratory failure. Methods: Following PRISMA 2020, we searched PubMed, Scopus and Web of Science to 31 October 2026. Two authors independently screened records, extracted data and assessed bias with QUADAS-2. Cohorts reporting the area under the curve (AUC), sensitivity, specificity or two-by-two data against NIV failure were eligible. Results were synthesised narratively. Results: Thirteen cohorts (5,916 patients) were included, with NIV failure rates of 8.9% to 59.4%. After 1-2 hours of NIV, the original score achieved AUCs of 0.65-0.91; at a threshold above 5, sensitivity ranged from 53.7% to 98.0% and specificity from 75.8% to 100%. The updated score achieved AUCs of 0.76-0.85 and outperformed the original version in all three comparative cohorts. The original score discriminated poorly when measured before NIV. Ten studies carried high risk of bias in the reference standard domain. Conclusion: Both scores showed acceptable to excellent discrimination after 1-2 hours of NIV, with better performance for the updated version. Specificity exceeded sensitivity at the conventional threshold in most cohorts. Prospective multicentre validation with prespecified thresholds is required.
References
1. Rochwerg B, Brochard L, Elliott MW, Hess D, Hill NS, Nava S, et al. Official ERS/ATS clinical practice guidelines: noninvasive ventilation for acute respiratory failure. Eur Respir J. 2017;50(2):1602426.
2. Bellani G, Laffey JG, Pham T, Madotto F, Fan E, Brochard L, et al. Noninvasive ventilation of patients with acute respiratory distress syndrome. Insights from the LUNG SAFE study. Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2017;195(1):67-77.
3. Demoule A, Girou E, Richard JC, Taille S, Brochard L. Benefits and risks of success or failure of noninvasive ventilation. Intensive Care Med. 2006;32(11):1756-65.
4. Carrillo A, Gonzalez-Diaz G, Ferrer M, Martinez-Quintana ME, Lopez-Martinez A, Llamas N, et al. Non-invasive ventilation in community-acquired pneumonia and severe acute respiratory failure. Intensive Care Med. 2012;38(3):458-66.
5. Kangelaris KN, Ware LB, Wang CY, Janz DR, Zhuo H, Matthay MA, et al. Timing of intubation and clinical outcomes in adults with acute respiratory distress syndrome. Crit Care Med. 2016;44(1):120-9.
6. Duan J, Han X, Bai L, Zhou L, Huang S. Assessment of heart rate, acidosis, consciousness, oxygenation, and respiratory rate to predict noninvasive ventilation failure in hypoxemic patients. Intensive Care Med. 2017;43(2):192-9.
7. Duan J, Chen L, Liu X, Bozbay S, Liu Y, Wang K, et al. An updated HACOR score for predicting the failure of noninvasive ventilation: a multicenter prospective observational study. Crit Care. 2022;26(1):196.
8. Duan J, Wang S, Liu P, Han X, Tian Y, Gao F, et al. Early prediction of noninvasive ventilation failure in COPD patients: derivation, internal validation, and external validation of a simple risk score. Ann Intensive Care. 2019;9(1):108.
9. Ding M, Han X, Bai L, Huang S, Duan J. Impact of HACOR score on noninvasive ventilation failure in non-COPD patients with acute-on-chronic respiratory failure. Can Respir J. 2021;2021:9960667.
10. Guia MF, Boléo-Tomé JP, Imitazione P, Polistina GE, Alves C, Ishikawa O, et al. Usefulness of the HACOR score in predicting success of CPAP in COVID-19-related hypoxemia. Respir Med. 2021;187:106550.
11. Santus P, Pini S, Amati F, Saad M, Gatti M, Mondoni M, et al. Predictors of helmet CPAP failure in COVID-19 pneumonia: a prospective, multicenter, and observational cohort study. Can Respir J. 2022;2022:1499690.
12. Mathen PG, Kumar KPG, Mohan N, Sreekrishnan TP, Nair SB, Krishnan AK, et al. Prediction of noninvasive ventilation failure in a mixed population visiting the emergency department in a tertiary care center in India. Indian J Crit Care Med. 2022;26(10):1115-9.
13. Chong CY, Bustam A, Noor Azhar M, Abdul Latif AK, Ismail R, Poh K. Evaluation of HACOR scale as a predictor of non-invasive ventilation failure in acute cardiogenic pulmonary oedema patients: a prospective observational study. Am J Emerg Med. 2024;79:19-24.
14. Anand A, Kodamanchili ST, Joshi A, Joshi R, Sharma JP, Abhishek G, et al. Longitudinal assessment of ROX and HACOR scores to predict non-invasive ventilation failure in patients with SARS-CoV-2 pneumonia. J Crit Care Med (Targu Mures). 2024;10(2):147-57.
15. Watson A, Yadollahi S, Fahmy A, Mahar S, Fritche D, Beecham R, et al. Non-invasive ventilation for community-acquired pneumonia: outcomes and predictors of failure from an ICU cohort. Medicina (Kaunas). 2024;60(1):81.
16. Waghmare SR, Thorve S, Karpe S, Mishra H, Shenurkar A, Gurme S, et al. Utility of HACOR score in patients with acute exacerbation of post-tuberculosis obstructive airway disease: a retrospective observational study. J Assoc Physicians India. 2024;72(8):26-9.
17. da Silva MPN, Lunardi AC. Comparison of the clinimetric properties of the two versions of the HACOR scale for predicting noninvasive ventilation failure in Brazilian patients. Acute Crit Care. 2025;40(2):322-9.
18. Shekhar S, Ramu R, Senthilnathan M, Sekar D. Validation of the updated HACOR score for predicting non-invasive ventilation failure in acute hypoxemic respiratory failure. Indian J Med Res. 2026. doi:10.25259/IJMR_1214_2026.
19. Brochard L, Slutsky A, Pesenti A. Mechanical ventilation to minimize progression of lung injury in acute respiratory failure. Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2017;195(4):438-42.
20. Carteaux G, Millán-Guilarte T, De Prost N, Razazi K, Abid S, Thille AW, et al. Failure of noninvasive ventilation for de novo acute hypoxemic respiratory failure: role of tidal volume. Crit Care Med. 2016;44(2):282-90.
21. Tonelli R, Fantini R, Tabbì L, Castaniere I, Pisani L, Pellegrino MR, et al. Early inspiratory effort assessment by esophageal manometry predicts noninvasive ventilation outcome in de novo respiratory failure. A pilot study. Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2020;202(4):558-67.
22. Roca O, Caralt B, Messika J, Samper M, Sztrymf B, Hernández G, et al. An index combining respiratory rate and oxygenation to predict outcome of nasal high-flow therapy. Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2019;199(11):1368-76.
23. Praphruetkit N, Boonchana N, Monsomboon A, Ruangsomboon O. ROX index versus HACOR scale in predicting success and failure of high-flow nasal cannula in the emergency department for patients with acute hypoxemic respiratory failure: a prospective observational study. Int J Emerg Med. 2023;16(1):3.
24. Valencia CF, Lucero OD, Castro OC, Sanko AA, Olejua PA. Comparison of ROX and HACOR scales to predict high-flow nasal cannula failure in patients with SARS-CoV-2 pneumonia. Sci Rep. 2021;11(1):22559.
25. Mannarino MR, Bianconi V, Cosentini E, Figorilli F, Natali C, Cellini G, et al. The HACOR score predicts worse in-hospital prognosis in patients hospitalized with COVID-19. J Clin Med. 2022;11(12):3509.
26. Hartley T, Lane ND, Steer J, et al. The NIV Outcomes (NIVO) score: prediction of in-hospital mortality in exacerbations of COPD requiring assisted ventilation. Eur Respir J. 2021;58(2):2004042.
27. Yu H, Saffaran S, Ali A, Henry C, Mustfa N, Thomas A, et al. In-hospital testing of NIVPredict: an AI tool for early prediction of non-invasive ventilation outcome in acute respiratory failure. Crit Care. 2026;30(1). doi:10.1186/s13054-026-05894-1.
28. Kheir M, Dong V, Roselli V, Mina B. The role of ultrasound in predicting non-invasive ventilation outcomes: a systematic review. Front Med (Lausanne). 2023;10:1233518.


